I've read this thread, and enjoyed watching the games. I've watched almost all of what's been posted thus far, though I usually skip the first 1.5 minutes to get to the point where there is an infantry rush (or isn't) since all the games seem identical more or less to that point. So, the purpose of this tournament is loosely stated to encourage new people to be into TS, or build the community, or something?
Some comments from someone new;
1) Could you please use consistent names? In the videos you did commentary for, you regularly called Phatmouse Ray. And you did the same in the tournament roster; http://challonge.com/tstournament2 . Can you get his user name changed to Ray? It would make things easier to follow.
2) I've been playing through the old C&C's 1 by 1 (playing 5-10 online games and the campaigns) and finished C&C1 and RA1. I'm halfway through the TS campaign (almost done GDI). In some C&C1 Videos found here:https://forums.cncnet.org/index.php?topic=5851.0 , the people commenting on the videos do a really good job on commenting on every little move. Equally, when I watch Starcraft stuff, same thing.
For comparison, there is little commentary on some things you consider obvious; a lot of the meta, for example. Why people are selling ref's instead of building structures and buying harvesters, why people are selling the refs instead of just keeping them and building more power, why what units get used when, why do we see infantry rushes even though they never seem to actually go anywhere? Why does Nod in particular have to defend against infantry rushes (no disc trooper)? Why do we see so little Nod played? The longest Nod game I see is ~15 minutes long and it's not clear if there would ever be a Nod endgame. Why do people always send 3 engineers in APC's, and why do they so often go for refinery's over CC's? (Same with disruptors; tend to go refinery over CC?)
It's sort of assumed that everyone watching is already a reasonably serious Tiberium Sun player...which is probably expected to be true. If there is also the goal of engaging newer players, maybe some more thorough commentary would help? Also, some of the guys in the chat seem to have microphones really poorly set up? Also, like, a bit of excitement, maybe? A lot of my favourite Starcraft sportscasters sound like they're excited to watch the match and enjoying the moves...you guys sound a little like these games are all by rote.
I really do quite look forward to watching a few more matches --- I'm hoping the finals get recorded/got recorded?